Creating a Job Ad That Attracts Top Talent: What to Include, What to Leave Out, and Why

·  5 minutes read

Job ads are more than just announcements; they’re an invitation to potential candidates, a reflection of your company culture, and often the first impression people get of your brand. 

In other words, writing a job ad isn’t just another HR formality—it’s a strategic move that could make or break your recruitment efforts. Let’s explore what to include, what to leave out, how long your job ad should be, and most importantly, why these factors matter.

Why Job Ads Matter

An effective job ad does more than list responsibilities; it showcases your company’s values, vision, and needs. Well-crafted job ads can significantly increase the quality and diversity of your applicant pool. A great ad not only attracts more applicants but the right applicants.

Key benefits of a strong job ad include:

  • Attracting top talent: When your ad is compelling, high-quality candidates are more likely to apply.
  • Saving time: Fewer irrelevant applications mean less time spent filtering through resumes.
  • Strengthening employer brand: A detailed, honest ad portrays authenticity, which can improve your organization’s reputation.

What to Include in a Job Ad

HR manager assembling five color-coded puzzle pieces on a table—symbolizing the key elements of a strong job ad: title, role description, skills, culture, and benefits.

1. A Clear, Specific Job Title

  • Why it matters: Vague titles like “Rockstar” or “Ninja” might sound fun, but they can confuse candidates and reduce search visibility. Use industry-standard terms (e.g., “Software Engineer,” “Marketing Manager”) so people know exactly what they’re applying for.
  • Evidence: Specific job titles with clear seniority levels (e.g., “Senior Accountant” vs. “Accountant”) attract more qualified candidates because they better match search queries.

2. Transparent Role Description & Responsibilities

  • Why it matters: Transparency builds trust and helps candidates self-select. Outline day-to-day tasks and long-term goals.
  • What it looks like: Use bullet points to describe responsibilities. Avoid overused buzzwords like “detail-oriented” or “team player” because, as many hiring managers point out, most candidates will always say yes to these qualities. Instead, focus on specific deliverables (e.g., “Manage and optimize PPC campaigns with monthly budgets over $20,000”).

3. Essential Skills & Qualifications

  • Why it matters: Making your must-have and nice-to-have skills clear helps you attract suitable candidates and avoid wasted time.
  • Pro Tip: Clearly separate required vs. preferred qualifications. 

4. Company Culture & Values

  • Why it matters: Many job seekers want a culture that matches their personal values. Briefly describe your core mission, culture, or team ethos.
  • Example: “We embrace remote work and flexible hours because we believe in work-life balance.”

5. Compensation & Benefits (Whenever Possible)

  • Why it matters: Salary transparency is increasingly important to today’s job seekers, and it can help filter out candidates who may have mismatched salary expectations.
  • Data Point: Job ads that include salary ranges and clear benefits experience 27% higher application rates.

What to Leave Out (and Why)

1. Overused Buzzwords

Phrases like “detail-oriented,” “team player,” or “fast learner” are so universal that nearly everyone checks these boxes. Instead, list specific tasks that demonstrate these qualities in action.

2. Unrealistic Requirements

Asking for 10 years of experience for an entry-level role or expecting mastery in an array of unrelated tools can deter potentially great candidates. Companies often inflate requirements, missing out on strong talent who may be discouraged by unrealistic expectations.

3. Discriminatory Language

Avoid any wording that could be seen as excluding certain groups (e.g., referencing a preferred age range). Beyond being unethical, it’s likely illegal depending on your location.

4. Irrelevant Perks or Exaggerations

Mentioning a never-ending supply of coffee is nice but don’t overdo it. Stick to the perks that truly matter to your ideal candidate, such as healthcare, flexible schedules, or professional development budgets.

Best Practices and Common Pitfalls

HR leader pointing to a color-coded roadmap with four symbolic milestones, illustrating best practices and common pitfalls in crafting job ads.

1. Clarity is King

  • Do: Write short paragraphs, use bullet points, and employ headings.
  • Don’t: Let the ad become a long block of text.

2. Use a Consistent Voice

  • Do: Reflect your company culture—serious, playful, or somewhere in between.
  • Don’t: Alternate between overly formal language and casual slang.

3. Avoid “Always-Yes” Traits

  • Do: Highlight unique requirements or tasks.
  • Don’t: Waste space on traits everyone claims to have, such as “good communicator.”

4. Encourage Applications

  • Do: Provide clear instructions on how to apply and whom to contact.
  • Don’t: Set vague or confusing application processes that drive candidates away.

The Bigger Picture: Pricing, Challenges, and Comparisons

  • Pricing/Costs: A poorly written ad can be costly—time wasted on unsuitable candidates and potentially higher turnover.
  • Problems/Challenges: The main challenge is striking the right balance between being thorough and concise. Overly long ads can appear cumbersome, yet extremely short ones may seem incomplete.
  • Comparisons: Traditional ads often just list requirements and responsibilities. Modern ads focus on culture, growth opportunities, and authentic language.

Conclusion

A recruiter and new hire shaking hands confidently in a bright office reception, symbolizing the success of crafting compelling job ads that attract top talent.

Creating an effective job ad is a strategic art. It’s about clarity, honesty, and knowing what truly matters to your target candidates. While length can vary, content that captivates the reader is essential. Avoid overused buzzwords and give candidates a clear picture of both the role and your company culture. By doing so, you’ll stand out from the sea of job postings and attract the qualified, engaged applicants you need.

Talk With Our Hiring Experts

Want to see how we help our clients with a winning, AI-powered hiring process? Schedule a demo and meet our experts to redefine your hiring strategy. 

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational purposes and may not cover all specific requirements in your jurisdiction. Always consult legal or HR experts to ensure compliance with local labor laws.

Content

    Fletcher Wimbush  ·  CEO at Discovered.AI
    Fletcher Wimbush · CEO at Discovered.AI
    Subscribe to our newsletter